There is something extraordinary about the sense of entitlement that can accompany fervent pro-Israel advocacy in the UN, particularly when those involved apparently feel entitled to use the UN’s administrative and investigative machinery to extend the same bullying and intimidation tactics employed by the Israeli government into the workplace.
A P-4 Political Affairs Officer, whose nationality and political inclinations are not disclosed in the judgment, although readers may easily draw their own conclusions, filed a formal complaint against a D-1 Director following a disagreement during a trivia game at a UN social gathering. The subject of this extraordinary dispute?
The P-4 insisted that the word “abracadabra” was of Hebrew origin, while the D-1 maintained that it was Persian.
The P-4 accused the D-1 of shouting at him and engaging in “cultural propaganda”.
The OIOS carried out the investigation.
And
Abracadabra!
They found that the D-1 had “failed to act as a role model for his Office” and referred the matter for appropriate action.
The matter was closed because, frankly, the whole thing was nonsense. Or so you think…
When the D-1 staff member, who is clearly of Arab origin, submitted a complaint of “racial and ethnic discrimination” against the P-4, OIOS quickly closed it. And when he submitted a second complaint alleging a malicious complaint motivated by ethnic discrimination, a “plot” and a “staff mutiny”, it didn’t go anywhere either.
OIOS dismissed both complaints as mere rebuttals of the P-4’s original allegations, finding “no new information warranting further action”.
When he went to the UN Dispute Tribunal, the UNDT dismissed the matter as not receivable.
Two days ago, UNAT reversed the decision.
In Jedian v. Secretary-General of the United Nations, Judgment No. 2026-UNAT-1697, published 11 November 2026, the Appeals Tribunal found that OIOS had treated the D-1’s independent discrimination complaints as mere rebuttals of the original complaint, thereby diminishing their standing as independent allegations of prohibited conduct.
It also found that the UNDT had failed to apply the relevant legal framework and had departed from established jurisprudence concerning the right to challenge the handling of complaints of prohibited conduct.
The Appeals Tribunal concluded:
“The UNDT erred in finding that Mr. Jedian’s application was not receivable ratione materiae.”
It reversed the judgment and ordered the case returned to the Dispute Tribunal for consideration by a different judge.
While this judgment about etymology and abracadabra might seem trivial, you should read between the lines and consider what it reveals about the extent to which pro-Israel influence may be permeating every aspect of the UN, including its internal accountability machinery.
When a government can engage in bullying and carries out a genocide with apparent impunity, it is hardly surprising that its most fervent supporters might feel equally entitled to intimidate Arab colleagues within the UN itself, apparently confident that the Organization’s own machinery will accommodate them.
Kudos to the D-1 Director for pursuing the case when others wouldn’t have cared once the original matter was closed. Clearly, he understood that this was never about abracadabra, but rather about teaching Zionists a lesson. And he was absolutely right to do so.
Never underestimate the need to rebut all these insidious attempts to diminish Arab voices and Arab origins.
This is not a Trivial Pursuit